2023 (Overall 7-18, League 2-10):
| Kori Villeneuve | Team MVP Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Gabriella DiFrancesco | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Jianna Lopez | Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Olivia Williams | Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) |
| Sienna Snyder | Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) Team Coaches Award |
| Maia Helmar | Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) |
| Alexis Vanhorn | Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) |
| Harper Lohman | Varsity Scholar (GPA 3.8+) |
| Suzana Mosa | JV – Team MVP |
| Sophie Fladrois | JV – Team Coaches Award |
2022 (Overall 19-6, League 6-3):
| McKayla Cotton | Team MVP All-League – 1st Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Dru Stinson | Coach’s Award All-League – 1st Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Ava Nolan | All-League – 1st Team |
| Sydni Griffin | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Charlotte Coder | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2021 (Overall 16-9, League 8-1):
| Eliana Gottlieb | Sunset Wave League Most Valuable Player All-League 1st Team Team MVP 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| McKayla Cotton | Sunset Wave League Most Valuable Pitcher All-League 1st Team |
| Lily Larkins | All-League – 1st Team Team Most Improved Player 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Lindsey Blanchfield | All-League – 1st Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Ava Nolan | All-League – 1st Team Team Rooking of the Year |
| Kendall Kelly | All-League – 2nd Team Team Coaches Award 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Alexis Amaro | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2019 (Overall 18-10, League 8-1):
| Eliana Gottlieb | All-CIF Southern Section Division 5 OC Register All-County 3rd Team Sunset Wave League Most Valuable Player All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week Albano’s Diamond Club Orange County Standout of the Week |
| Clare Austin | Sunset Wave League Most Valuable Pitcher All-League – 1st Team |
| Lindsey Blanchfield | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team – 2nd Team |
| Leah Freeman | All-League – 1st Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Kendall Kelly | All-League – 1st Team |
| McKayla Cotton | All-League – 2nd Team |
| Tom Blanchfield | Daily Pilot Coach of the Year |
2018 (Overall 6-21, League 0-10):
| Lindsey Blanchfield | All-League – 2nd Team |
| Eliana Gottlieb | Daily Pilot Dream Team – 2nd Team |
| Aliea Tvedt | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2017:
| Leah Freeman | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team – 2nd Team |
| Diana Surber | All-League – 2nd Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Skialer Carter | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Lesly De La Rosa | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Samantha Del Toro | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Kendall Machado | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2016:
| Leah Freeman | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Player of the Year |
| Samantha Del Toro | Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Kendall Machado | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Haley Martinez | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Ashley McNerney | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2015:
| Diana Surber | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Ashley McNerney | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Shea Horvath | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Tanner Rodriguez | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2014:
| Shea Horvath | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Sylvanna Barrios | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Kendall Blanchfield | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Mariah Cruz | Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
2013:
| Hattie Marshall | Orange County Coaches All Stars All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Player of the Year Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Breanna Lopez | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Lauren Gandi | Daily Pilot Dream Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Zoey Myers | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Hope Noakes | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Hanna Van Voorhis | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2012:
| Hattie Marshall | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Player of the Year Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Lauren Gandi | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Jordan Blanchfield | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Breanna Lopez | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
2011:
| Bella Secaira | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Player of the Year Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Hattie Marshall | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Savannah Caviston | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Amanda LeGault | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
2010:
| Bella Secaira | All-League – 1st Team |
| Alex Bauer | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
2009:
| Karina Veit | All-League – 1st Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2008:
| Jane Messersmith | Orange County vs Riverside County All Stars All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Alex Bauer | All-League – 2nd Team |
| Robin Gautschi | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Lauren Talbott | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2007:
| Jane Messersmith | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Kristin Bassler | All-League – 1st Team |
| Casey Lucas | All-League – 2nd Team |
2006:
| Jane Messersmith | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Darci Pennington | All-League – 2nd Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Robin Gautschi | All-League – Honorable Mention Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Katie Daniels | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Casey Lucas | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Lauren Talbott | All-League – Honorable Mention |
2005:
| Ashley Gleason | Orange County Coaches All Stars All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Julianne Bass | Orange County Coaches All Stars All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Jane Messersmith | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Robin Gautschi | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Darci Pennington | All-League – Honorable Mention |
2004:
| Ashley Gleason | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Julianne Bass | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Jennifer Gummerman | All-League – Honorable Mention 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Sasha Grumman | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Kayleigh Horn | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Darci Pennington | All-League – Honorable Mention |
2003:
| Athena Vasquez | Orange County Coaches All Stars All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Kim Moore | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Ashley Gleason | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Julianne Bass | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Shelby Crisp | All-League – Honorable Mention 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Amanda Campbell | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
| Sabrina Couch | 4 Year Varsity Letter Winner |
2002:
| Athena Vasquez | All-League – 1st Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Kim Moore | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Amanda Campbell | All-League – 2nd Team Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Sabrina Couch | All-League – Honorable Mention Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Shelby Crisp | All-League – Honorable Mention Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Ashely Gleason | All-League – Honorable Mention Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Julianne Bass | All-League – Honorable Mention |
| Bailey Bearden | All-League – Honorable Mention |
2001:
| Athena Vasquez | Daily Pilot Dream Team Daily Pilot Athlete of the Week |
| Bailey Bearden | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Shelby Crisp | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Lisa Huntington | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
2000:
| Amanda Cambell | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Lisa Huntington | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Lindsay Moore | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Kristen Smith | Daily Pilot Dream Team |
| Athena Vasquez | Daily Pilot Dream Team |